Pleading to a Lesser Included Offense in Houston > FAQ | Houston Top Criminal Defense Attorneys at The Haggard Law Firm

 
What does it require to allow a jury at trial to consider a lesser included offense??

Getting a lesser included test requires: (a) that the lesser offense must actually be a lesser-included offense of the charged offense, as defined by Article 37.09 V.A.C.C.P. and (b) that the record must contain some evidence that permits a rational jury to find that the Defendant is guilty only of the lesser-included offense.

What must the evidence demonstrate in order the a jury to be allowed to consider a lesser-incuded offense?

The evidence must demonstrate that the lesser-included offense is a valid, rational alternative to the charged offense.

How does the Court determine in a trial whether such a jury instruction is appropriate?

In determining whether the instruction is appropriate, the Court evaluates the evidence in the context of the entire record, but does not consider whether the evidence is credible, controverted, or in conflict with other evidence.

How much evidence in the record is necessary to justify allowing a jury to consider that a Defendant is guilty only of the lesser-included offense?

Anything more than a scintilla of evidence may be sufficient to entitle a Defendant to a lesser charge and when a trial court improperly refuses a properly requested instruction on a lesser-included offense, a finding of harm is automatic because the jury was denied the opportunity to convict of the lesser offense.

 

---

~The Haggard Law Firm accepts selected criminal defense cases in Harris, Fort Bend, Galveston, Brazoria, Montgomery, Matagorda and surrounding Texas counties. Affordable representation; payment plans arranged in some cases. We represent clients in all Misdemeanor Courts, Felony Courts, Juvenile Court and Federal Court.~
Copyright © 2012 The Haggard Law Firm

*Evidence of prior performance should not be taken as a guarantee of future success. All cases are unique and must be handled on an individual basis. Tactics, strategies, and defenses will vary. This is not a comprehensive career-long (since 1973) listing within this category of charges but is intended as a recent and representative sample only.

Note: Clients have given their permission for any testimonials presented here.